Re: Our first potential flame war: which scripting language?

Andrew M. Kuchling (akuchlin@cnri.reston.va.us)
Thu, 27 Aug 1998 16:17:28 -0400 (EDT)


>Hence, you should (IMO) base your decision on how much *power* the language has
>and how much unsolicited popularity it has, not on an aesthetic judgement of
>how the language looks. IMO, JavaScript is fair to poor in terms of

It's not yet obvious to me that sheer language power is
required, because the uses to which the language will be put aren't
yet in focus. I repeat, is it going to be used for relatively simple
macros, or for plug-in applications that need to crunch relatively
complex data structures? If the former, than language expressiveness
is irrelevant; all you need is to write things like forward_words(5) ;
insert_text('Hi!'). It's also not hard to generate such code
sequences by recording actions or in a wizard of some sort.

Let's make this concrete. Can someone make a list of two or
three things that would be done using the scripting language?

>*and* power. Python is sort of powerful, but also is pretty unknown (the
>O'Reilly book is the only one I know about on the language).

We're hackers, and are supposed to make decisions on technical
merit, not popularity; on popularity alone, we'd all be using
Windows. :) And on ease-of-use for inexperienced programmers,
Javascript or Python are clear wins over Tcl and Perl, because they're
simpler.

-- 
A.M. Kuchling			http://starship.skyport.net/crew/amk/
Planet Bog---Pools of toxic chemicals bubble under a choking atmosphere of
poisonous gases... but aside from that, it's not much like Earth.
    -- Bill Watterson, _The Authoritative Calvin and Hobbes_


This archive was generated by hypermail 1.03b2.